BERT Question Answering Embedding Python* Demo

This README describes the Question Answering Embedding demo application that uses a Squad-tuned BERT model to calculate embedding vectors for context and question to find right context for question. The primary difference from the bert_question_answering_demo is that this demo demonstrates how the inference can be accelerated via pre-computing the embeddings for the contexts.

How It Works

On startup the demo application reads command line parameters and loads network(s) to the InferenceEngine. It also fetches data from the user-provided urls to populate the list of "contexts" with the text. Prior to the actual inference to answer user's questions, the embedding vectors are pre-calculated (via inference) for each context from the list. This is done using the first ("emdbeddings-only") BERT model.

After that, when user types a question, the "embeddings" network is used to calculate an embedding vector for the specified question. Using the L2 distance between the embedding vector of the question and the embedding vectors for the contexts the best (closest) contexts are selected as candidates to further seek for the final answer to the question. At this point, the contexts are displayed to the user.

Notice that question is usually much shorter than the contexts, so calculating the embedding for that is really fast. Also calculating the L2 distance between a context and question is almost free, compared to the actual inference. Together, during question answering, this substantially saves on the actual inference, which is needed ONLY for the question (while contexts are pre-calculated), compared to the conventional approach that has to concatenate each context with the question and do an inference on this large input (per context).

If second (conventional SQuAD-tuned) Bert model is provided as well, it is used to further search for the exact answer in the best contexts found in the first step, and the result then also displayed to the user.

Preparing to Run

The list of models supported by the demo is in <omz_dir>/demos/bert_question_answering_embedding_demo/python/models.lst file. This file can be used as a parameter for Model Downloader and Converter to download and, if necessary, convert models to OpenVINO Inference Engine format (*.xml + *.bin).

An example of using the Model Downloader:

python3 <omz_dir>/tools/downloader/downloader.py --list models.lst

An example of using the Model Converter:

python3 <omz_dir>/tools/downloader/converter.py --list models.lst

Supported Models

  • bert-large-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-0001
  • bert-large-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-emb-0001
  • bert-large-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-int8-0001
  • bert-small-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-0001
  • bert-small-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-0002
  • bert-small-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-emb-int8-0001
  • bert-small-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-int8-0002
  • bert-large-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-emb-0001
  • bert-small-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-emb-int8-0001

NOTE: Refer to the tables Intel's Pre-Trained Models Device Support and Public Pre-Trained Models Device Support for the details on models inference support at different devices.

Running

Running the application with the -h option yields the following usage message:

usage: bert_question_answering_embedding_demo.py [-h] -i INPUT
[--questions QUESTION [QUESTION ...]]
[--best_n BEST_N] -v VOCAB
-m_emb MODEL_EMB
[--input_names_emb INPUT_NAMES_EMB]
[-m_qa MODEL_QA]
[--input_names_qa INPUT_NAMES_QA]
[--output_names_qa OUTPUT_NAMES_QA]
[-a MAX_ANSWER_TOKEN_NUM]
[-d DEVICE] [-c]
Options:
-h, --help Show this help message and exit.
-i INPUT, --input INPUT
Required. Urls to a wiki pages with context
--questions QUESTION [QUESTION ...]
Optional. Prepared questions
--best_n BEST_N Optional. Number of best (closest) contexts selected
-v VOCAB, --vocab VOCAB
Required. Path to vocabulary file with tokens
-m_emb MODEL_EMB, --model_emb MODEL_EMB
Required. Path to an .xml file with a trained model to
build embeddings
--input_names_emb INPUT_NAMES_EMB
Optional. Names for inputs in MODEL_EMB network. For
example 'input_ids,attention_mask,token_type_ids','pos
ition_ids'
-m_qa MODEL_QA, --model_qa MODEL_QA
Optional. Path to an .xml file with a trained model to
give exact answer
--input_names_qa INPUT_NAMES_QA
Optional. Names for inputs in MODEL_QA network. For
example 'input_ids,attention_mask,token_type_ids','pos
ition_ids'
--output_names_qa OUTPUT_NAMES_QA
Optional. Names for outputs in MODEL_QA network. For
example 'output_s,output_e'
-a MAX_ANSWER_TOKEN_NUM, --max_answer_token_num MAX_ANSWER_TOKEN_NUM
Optional. Maximum number of tokens in exact answer
-d DEVICE, --device DEVICE
Optional. Specify the target device to infer on; CPU
is acceptable. The demo will look for a suitable plugin
for device specified. Default value is CPU
-c, --colors Optional. Nice coloring of the questions/answers.
Might not work on some terminals (like Windows* cmd
console)

Example Demo Cmd-Line

You can use the following command to try the demo:

python3 bert_question_answering_embedding_demo.py
--vocab=<omz_dir>/models/intel/bert-small-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-0002/vocab.txt
--model_emb=<path_to_model>/bert-large-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-emb-0001.xml
--input_names_emb="input_ids,attention_mask,token_type_ids,position_ids"
--model_qa=<path_to_model>/bert-small-uncased-whole-word-masking-squad-0002.xml
--input_names_qa="input_ids,attention_mask,token_type_ids,position_ids"
--output_names_qa="output_s,output_e"
--input="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bert_(Sesame_Street)"
--input="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_light"
-c

The demo will use the Wikipedia articles about the Bert character and the speed of light to answer your questions like "what is the speed of light", "how to measure the speed of light", "who is Bert", "how old is Bert", etc.

Demo Inputs

The application reads text from the HTML pages at the given urls and then answers questions typed from the console. The models and its parameters (inputs and outputs) are also important demo arguments. Notice that since order of inputs for the model does matter, the demo script checks that the inputs specified from the command line match the actual network inputs. The embedding model is reshaped by the demo to infer embedding vectors for long contexts and short question. Make sure that the original model converted by Model Optimizer with reshape option. Please see general reshape intro and limitations

Demo Outputs

The application outputs contexts with answers to the same console.

Classifying Documents with Long Texts

Notice that when the original "context" (paragraph text from the url) alone or together with the question do not fit the model input (usually 384 tokens for the Bert-Large, or 128 for the Bert-Base), the demo splits the paragraph into overlapping segments. Thus, for the long paragraph texts, the network is called multiple times as for separate contexts.

Demo Performance

Even though the demo reports inference performance (by measuring wall-clock time for individual inference calls), it is only baseline performance, as certain tricks like batching, throughput mode can be applied. Please use the full-blown Benchmark C++ Sample for any actual performance measurements.

See Also